Upcoming Elections

Where every candidate on your ballot stands on Flock cameras.

College Station City Council

Mayor

  • Bob Yancy

    Council record Voted no on renewing the Flock contracts, Sept. 24, 2026.

    Watch the meeting · 3:46:37
    At the Sept. 24 council vote

    The problem is the vendor's open architecture, their initial lack of concern for privacy in its initial design, and the company itself. Flock collects too much, it shares with too many, it uses inflexible contract language and marketing doublespeak.

    More from the meeting (1)

    They're probably not going to survive the legal expenses alone with the lawsuits that they have. They're undergoing layoffs, according to The Wall Street Journal. They've got targeted legislation that uniquely goes after their software architecture. They're hemorrhaging clients all over the country…

    WTAW 1620 interview · before the vote

    I was the first on council to identify the problematic contract provisions in the Flock contract. Basically, what Flock does is it's akin to me saying, ‘I have an empty lot next to my house and I'm going to sell it to you… you own it, but I retain the ability to do anything I want…’ So, technically, you own it, but do you really? Flock does the same thing with data.

    More from this interview (2)

    But then on the other side, it does so much good. It has literally saved abducted children, collared bad guys.

    Axon offers a product that significantly constrains and silos the data within the community that they serve… whereas Flock is just kind of this wide open, AI-powered, looking for a guy in a red shirt.

  • WTAW 1620 interview

    I would like a voter accountable person watching if we decide to continue Flock.

    More from this interview (3)

    Flock cameras, I think, are going to have to be legislated at the state level because when you're talking about data sharing, you're crossing county lines and at that point, it's better to have the state weigh in.

    I'm glad that Flock has made some changes… but I also want government oversight. Like, that's so important.

    I also want some local audit that is voter accountable… I want the mayors or the council members to be able to go in and look at those audits… and make sure what we're doing with our data and exactly how it's being handled and who's using it… Don't just tell me that Flock's going to watch itself.

Place 1

  • Mark Smith

    Council record Voted no on renewing the Flock contracts, Sept. 24, 2026.

    Watch the meeting · 3:41:35
    At the Sept. 24 council vote

    Flock Safety is a valuable tool for the police department, but the lack of public trust is a serious concern.

    More from the meeting (2)

    Based on the information that I am hearing today, I'm going to vote against keeping the Flock camera. I also want to do that while we work towards clear, enforceable guardrails.

    We can not have it while we solve these problems.

    WTAW 1620 interview · day of the vote

    I will vote to not extend the contract… I think that the privacy concerns have not been adequately addressed and that's really a real problem.

    More from this interview (1)

    With Flock or another brand, if that database is in the cloud, it is more vulnerable.

  • WTAW 1620 interview

    I would have voted to keep it for a year, but we need to seriously, seriously look at: is Flock the right program to be involved with?

    More from this interview (2)

    ALPRs have been around for a long, long time, and they definitely have their benefits.

    There's some other programs out there that we really need to take a hard look at. And just because we keep it for a year doesn't mean we're keeping it permanently.

  • Roy May

    Position changed Now says no to continued Flock use.

    Written response to DeflockBCS · Oct. 2026

    No. I do not support College Station continuing to use Flock but we do use license scanners in police vehicles which I support (there is a safety element to that for our officers).

    Read his full response

    Do you support College Station continuing to use Flock Safety or similar ALPR camera systems?

    No. I do not support College Station continuing to use Flock but we do use license scanners in police vehicles which I support (there is a safety element to that for our officers).

    My position has changed as I've learned more about the technology, the size of the network, how much information is being collected, how long that information can be retained, and the potential for it to be accessed outside College Station. I initially believed Flock could be a useful law enforcement tool if strong enough guardrails were put in place. I no longer believe those guardrails adequately address the fundamental privacy concerns that come with routinely recording the movements of hundreds of thousands of vehicles driven by people suspected of absolutely nothing. I understand that CSPD has had successes using Flock, and I don't dismiss those. But for me, the public-safety benefit no longer outweighs the broader concern of creating and maintaining that kind of surveillance network. My answer today is no.

    What safeguards, if any, do you believe should be required regarding data retention, searches, access by outside law-enforcement agencies, and sharing of College Station's ALPR network?

    This is one of the areas that has caused me to become more concerned. Earlier this year, College Station was operating under a 30-day retention period. Flock has since moved toward recommending a much shorter seven-day retention period (outside of active investigations), but College Station did not opt into that change. That bothers me. If the company providing the technology believes seven days is sufficient, I have a hard time understanding why the city needs to retain information on residents and visitors for 30 days when the overwhelming majority of those people are not suspected of committing any crime.

    If we continue using ALPR technology, retention should be as short as reasonably possible unless information is tied to an active investigation. Every search should require a legitimate law-enforcement purpose, reasonable suspicion and a case number, and every search should be auditable. I would also want very tight restrictions on outside access. College Station data should not become part of an effectively nationwide surveillance network simply because another agency uses the same vendor.

    Do you believe College Station residents should have a direct opportunity to vote on whether the city continues using this type of surveillance technology?

    I absolutely believe residents should have a much larger voice in this decision. Whether that ultimately means putting the issue directly on the ballot is something I would want to examine from both a legal and practical standpoint, but I understand why residents are asking for it. This isn't the same as buying another piece of police equipment. We're talking about technology capable of documenting where vehicles travel throughout our city, including those driven by people suspected of absolutely nothing. That raises legitimate questions about privacy, government surveillance and where we draw that line. Residents deserve a meaningful say in where that line is drawn.

    If elected, would you support greater public reporting or independent oversight of the city's ALPR system, including information about how frequently it is searched and which outside agencies access it?

    Yes. Absolutely.

    If College Station is going to operate an ALPR network, transparency should not be optional. I would support regular public reporting showing how many searches are conducted, the general reasons for those searches, how often the system produces useful investigative results, which outside agencies have access to College Station's network, how frequently those agencies search it, and whether any searches are flagged during audits. The system already logs searches. If that information already exists, I see no reason we cannot provide residents meaningful reporting while still protecting active investigations.

    Closing remarks

    My position on Flock has evolved. I started out looking at it primarily as a public-safety tool and believing strong guardrails could address most of my concerns. The more I've learned about the size of the network, the amount of information being collected, retention and the potential for information to be accessed outside College Station, the less comfortable I've become with it. Public safety matters. So does the expectation that government isn't unnecessarily tracking people who haven't done anything wrong.

    I also recognize that the current council has already voted to renew the Flock agreements, which limits what I can realistically change immediately if I'm elected. What I can do is continue asking questions, push for stronger safeguards and transparency, and ensure residents have a voice in how this technology is used going forward. I appreciate you taking the time to send me these questions. I completely understand why Flock has become such a hot-button issue in College Station, and the more I've learned about it, the more I understand those concerns. And again, I apologize for the delayed response.

    Earlier: WTAW 1620 interview (4)

    I'm not against Flock cameras. I'm just against this 30 days, less guardrails. I think all the audits and everything should be completely transparent.

    Flock came out on August 13th with a recommendation that said your data storage shouldn't be 30 days. It should be seven… And my question was, why haven't we opted into it?

    This is a system that is obviously assisting our officers. We just need to look at the guardrails and the guidelines.

    There should be just like a page on the city website that you can always go and look… We have a right to know how our data is being stored and who's accessing it.

Place 2

  • WTAW 1620 interview

    The straight answer is I think if there was no alternative, I would have left Flock on.

    More from this interview (3)

    I did speak in front of council about it, in favor of Flock.

    Do I like being looked at everywhere I go? No. But the other number that I'm concerned with is the number one, which is one victim, one crime solved, one crime not committed.

    It's a black and white issue to too many people. There's no middle ground at all… I think there's more room for discussion and I think we need to hear from both sides.

  • WTAW 1620 interview

    Asked: “If you'd been on council this week, would you have voted to renew the contract or not renew the contract?”

    I'd probably say no… I would have to have evidence really showing me that there's going to be safeguards… So, I would say no.

    More from this interview (2)

    I'm for and against it… If you're going to use it, there needs to be safeguards.

    I just don't like it when it comes to invading people's privacy.

Place 5 · Unexpired Term

  • Tre Watson

    Questionnaire response

    Asked: “If a vote were held today on renewing the city's Flock Safety contract in its current form, would you support or oppose renewal?”

    Oppose, but specifically because they won't agree to have [a] citizen oversight committee over CSPD.

    Read his full response

    How would you describe your general position on the use of ALPR technology?

    I believe ALPRs are helpful and have been useful in the past and we've had them for around a decade I believe. I would like to minimize the amount we have by only having them in the entrances of our city as well as major intersections. I would also like to look into what we were using before Flock and see if we could go back to that if they have safer tracking measures.

    Do you believe the city's current safeguards governing ALPR use are generally sufficient or insufficient?

    I definitely think people should be prosecuted for misuse of something that contains so much particular data.

    What additional transparency, auditing, or accountability measures, if any, would you support?

    Not fully informed enough to answer…

    Under what circumstances, if any, should law enforcement be prohibited from using ALPR data?

    I believe only certain people should be able to use them for certain reasons, possibly get a warrant like you would need for entering houses.

    What restrictions, if any, should apply to sharing or allowing other law-enforcement agencies to search the city's ALPR data?

    Same as last question…

    If a vote were held today on renewing the city's Flock Safety contract in its current form, would you support or oppose renewal?

    Oppose, but specifically because they won't agree to have [a] citizen oversight committee over CSPD.

    What information would cause you to reconsider your current position on ALPR technology?

    Approving a citizen oversight committee over CSPD.

    WTAW 1620 interview

    I believe that we do need LPRs, not [Flock] cameras. We do need LPRs at the entrances of our cities and major intersection points.

    More from this interview (3)

    I feel like LPRs… can be a very useful tool, but I don't feel like Flock and [Axon], all those cameras, should be everywhere.

    I believe we should have a citizen oversight committee for the police department and they don't agree. And so I don't understand why they should need any extra oversight over citizens if they don't want to give us oversight over them.

    I want to know who we were working with before Flock came around and to see how the community would feel if we went back that way.

  • Padon Holt

    Written response to DeflockBCS

    I would not have voted to renew the Flock camera contract at [the Sept. 24] City Council meeting because I truly believe the current, unregulated state of ALPR camera use leaves the door open for them to be used in ways that violate the Constitution's 4th Amendment.

    Read his full response

    I would not have voted to renew the Flock camera contract at [the Sept. 24] City Council meeting because I truly believe the current, unregulated state of ALPR camera use leaves the door open for them to be used in ways that violate the Constitution's 4th Amendment.

    At the same time, I would be open to their use once the federal judiciary renders their decisions on cases that are currently pending before them, particularly the Schmidt v City of Norfolk, VA case, which deals with the constitutionality of ALPR camera networks directly, in [addition] to the Texas legislature implementing Texas-specific regulation on this issue.

    I recognize the potential utility of ALPR cameras for our Police Department, which I've been endorsed by, but as an attorney, I'm a zealous advocate of and for the Constitution and the checks and balance mechanisms it contains. The relative newness of this technology means it needs to be processed through those systems to ensure our 4th Amendment rights are not sacrificed at the [altar] of technological progress.

    WTAW 1620 interview

    I do not think the city needs to renew the contracts with Flock cameras. That is not a position to where it's not a no never. It's just a no, not right now.

    More from this interview (2)

    This business segment, it needs to be regulated.

    It is getting litigated out to figure out… can these automatic license plate reader cameras… be used in a way that doesn't violate everybody's Fourth Amendment constitutional rights… So that's why I say no, not right now, and yes if regulated right.

  • Valen Cepak

    Read the post
    Campaign statement · Facebook

    I oppose Flock and ALPR technology.

    Read his full statement

    Flock & Public Safety in College Station

    From local news to The Washington Post, CNN, Fox, and now a U.S. Senate hearing, Flock has been under scrutiny and investigation. That investigation is warranted.

    Freedom in this country is not optional. It is the foundation of our way of life. Men and women have given their lives to protect it. After examining automatic license plate readers and Flock in particular, it is my judgment that the freedoms this nation was founded on, and has defended for more than 250 years, are being encroached upon by this technology.

    In the United States we take pride in the principle that you are innocent until proven guilty. Documented cases of wrongful identification and detention suggest this technology has too often inverted that principle: guilty until proven innocent.

    Should I prevail in November, I will place my hand on the Bible and swear an oath to defend and protect the Constitution, a Constitution worth defending. I oppose Flock and ALPR technology.

    A candidate who only names problems is not finished. The work is to propose a path. The data and operational experience show that alternatives such as Drone First Responders, and other emerging tools, can fill part of the gap until better technology arrives, technology Americans can support and officers can use with confidence.

    I trust our law enforcement. I am proud of the work of the College Station Police Department. I have watched this department enforce accountability and hold its officers to a high standard. No department is perfect. I trust that if there were misuse or poor judgment with these tools, CSPD would hold the responsible officers accountable. I believe we have one of the strongest departments in the state, and I want to equip them with new and emerging capabilities so they remain among the best.

    Beyond my own research and extensive conversations with officers, it is clear the community does not want this technology. I am elected by the people to represent the people. That is the job I intend to do as your councilman.

    WTAW 1620 interview

    I understand that they're a phenomenal tool for law enforcement and… I trust CSPD and their job, but when you have millions of searches going on in the state of Texas and our cameras being a part of that and having article after article about misuse of the system, that should be concerning.

    More from this interview (3)

    For us to be [flippant] and giving them up for these cameras, it feels dishonest and unfair to the guys who've laid their life down to protect those freedoms.

    These cameras, from everything I've done and all the homework I've researched, have every ability to turn into a similar style camera that we see that the CCP uses for social credit scores… I don't want a pathway to be created in the slightest to get to that.

    It's more like, well, you're guilty until proven innocent. And I'm just not comfortable with that.

Bryan City Council

Mayor

  • Bobby Gutierrez

    Council record Not present for the original Flock contract vote, Nov. 14, 2023 (Resolution 4071). Voted yes on expanding Flock cameras, March 10, 2026, as part of a unanimous consent agenda (Resolution 4169).

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

  • Rafael D. Pena III

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

Place 1

  • Paul Torres

    Council record Voted yes on the original Flock contract, Nov. 14, 2023 (Resolution 4071), and on expanding Flock cameras, March 10, 2026 (Resolution 4169). Both passed as part of a unanimous consent agenda.

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

  • Chris Scotti

    Questionnaire response

    Asked: “If a vote were held today on renewing the city's Flock Safety contract in its current form, would you support or oppose renewal?”

    I would not support renewing the contract in its current form without first addressing the oversight and data-sharing issues described above.

    Read his full response

    How would you describe your general position on the use of ALPR technology?

    I support ALPR technology for legitimate public-safety purposes, such as identifying stolen vehicles, investigating serious crimes, and locating missing or endangered people. I do not support allowing it to become an open-ended system for tracking the movements of ordinary citizens.

    Do you believe the city's current safeguards governing ALPR use are generally sufficient or insufficient?

    I believe the current safeguards are insufficient. My position has consistently been to support the technology with stronger oversight and clearly defined limits, particularly around access, retention, data sharing, auditing, and public transparency.

    What additional transparency, auditing, or accountability measures, if any, would you support?

    I would support publication of the City's ALPR policy, retention rules, data-sharing arrangements, and aggregate usage statistics. Searches should be tied to a legitimate law-enforcement purpose and logged so they can be audited. Supervisors should regularly review those logs, and the City should periodically report on compliance and any substantiated misuse. I would also support periodic independent review rather than relying exclusively on the vendor's own transparency tools.

    Under what circumstances, if any, should law enforcement be prohibited from using ALPR data?

    ALPR data should not be used for personal purposes, harassment or intimidation, routine traffic enforcement, or to target someone solely because of a protected characteristic. I would also oppose using it simply to monitor lawful political, religious, or other constitutionally protected activity without a legitimate criminal investigative basis.

    What restrictions, if any, should apply to sharing or allowing other law-enforcement agencies to search the city's ALPR data?

    I do not favor unlimited or indiscriminate access. An outside agency accessing Bryan data should have a legitimate law-enforcement purpose, operate under written rules that adequately protect the data, and have its searches logged and auditable. Bryan should know which agencies have continuing access and should be able to revoke that access when those standards are violated.

    If a vote were held today on renewing the city's Flock Safety contract in its current form, would you support or oppose renewal?

    I would not support renewing the contract in its current form without first addressing the oversight and data-sharing issues described above. I support legitimate public-safety uses of the technology, but contract renewal is the appropriate time for the City to make sure those safeguards are clearly established and enforceable.

    What information would cause you to reconsider your current position on ALPR technology?

    I am interested in results rather than being reflexively for or against a particular technology. Evidence that ALPRs are materially helping solve serious crimes supports their continued use. Documented misuse, inadequate auditing, excessive data sharing, security breaches, persistent false matches, or evidence that the public-safety benefit does not justify the scope or cost would cause me to reconsider how or whether the system should be used.

    I believe Bryan can give law enforcement effective tools while also putting meaningful safeguards in place to protect residents from misuse. Those two goals are not mutually exclusive.

    Facebook comment

    On the Flock cameras, I'm neither automatically for them nor against them. Technology can absolutely help law enforcement catch dangerous people and even save lives, but that doesn't mean we put a camera on every corner without strong guardrails. I want to see credible data on the public-safety benefits and equally good information about access, retention, sharing and potential abuse. My position will be driven by that evidence.

Place 2

  • Ray Arrington

    Council record Voted yes on the original Flock contract, Nov. 14, 2023 (Resolution 4071), and on expanding Flock cameras, March 10, 2026 (Resolution 4169). Both passed as part of a unanimous consent agenda.

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

  • Jeannette Stewart Moseley

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

  • Chrissy Ransome

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

Brazos County

Commissioner · Precinct 4

  • Wanda Watson

    Commissioners Court record Voted yes on the Flock camera system, Dec. 16, 2025 (CIP 26-519).

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

  • Peter Michelana

    Facebook comment

    [T]he more I find out about these, the more questions I have. My biggest frustration is why these were implemented without doing research and having a plan communicated to people. I was at commissioners court in December when the contract was voted on, and none of the information we have now was addressed.

Constable · Precinct 4

  • Hezekiah Carter Jr.

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

  • Guadalupe Arredondo

    No public statement on Flock cameras yet.

State of Texas

Candidate stances coming soon.